Massachusetts Medical Society
MA Forests
Facts on Biomass
"Biomass power plants pose an unacceptable risk to the public’s health..."Massachusetts Medical Society

Rally/Press Conference Urges Governor & Lt. Governor to Limit Biomass Subsidies

A statewide coalition of environmental, health and social justice groups is asking GovernorPatrick and Lt. Governor Murray to stand by the Administration’s 2010 pledge to limit ratepayer–funded incentives for biomass combustion power plants that burn wood for electricity.In the past 2 years, residents from across the state have signed over 135,000 petitions, postcards, letters and emails asking for stronger laws. Some groups are demanding a complete moratorium on state permits for biomass electricity until outstanding questions about health and climate change impacts are answered.

“The proposed regulations are a clear retreat from the sound science on biomass energy commissioned by the Administration and funded by Massachusetts taxpayers,” said James McCaffrey, Director of the Sierra Club’s Massachusetts’ Chapter. "We can only assumeindustry played a role in getting the Administration to back off its commitment to protect our forests, the environment, and public health. Massachusetts ratepayers should not be paying more for dirty, polluting forms of energy that worsen the impacts of climate change."

“After working hand-in-hand with the Patrick Administration to bring biomass energy incentives into line with the science-based analysis the Administration itself commissioned, we are dismayed to witness their swift retreat in the face of pressure from certain biomass industry interests,” said Sue Reid, Director of Conservation Law Foundation-Massachusetts. “These recent developments call into question the commitment to build a true clean energy economy.”

“Today we’re delivering 5,000 more petitions to the Patrick Administration. People are still outraged about these incinerators that burn trees for electricity. They have worse air pollution than coal and don’t deserve our clean energy money,” said Meg Sheehan, who ran the campaignin 2010 to get a ballot question to keep biomass combustion electricity out of the state’s renewable portfolio standard.

Toxics Action Project Center’s Director Sylvia Brodie said, “Common sense tells us burning wood is a significant source of particulate matter in our air. These fine particles can lodge in our lungs and cause breathing problems and disease. This is not something that we should be subsidizing."

Last year, Massachusetts Medical Society urged the Legislature to “remove government incentives for biomass combustion electricity plants.” American Lung Association also opposes incentives saying, “burning biomass could lead to significant increases in emissions of nitrogen oxides, particulate matter and sulfur dioxide and have severe impacts on the health of children, older adults, and people with lung diseases.”

Over twenty-four groups are calling for stronger regulations: Sierra Club, Conservation Law Foundation, Mass Audubon, Toxics Action Center, Clean Water Action Alliance of Massachusetts, Environmental League of Massachusetts, American Lung Association in New England, Environment Massachusetts, MassPIRG, Chelsea Creek Action Group, Massachusetts Breast Cancer Coalition, Natural Resources of Maine, Natural Resources Defense Council, The Wilderness Society, Clean Air Task Force, Greenpeace, Massachusetts Forest Watch, Concerned Citizens of Franklin County, Massachusetts, Concerned Citizens of Russell, Massachusetts, ARISE for Social Justice, Springfield, Massachusetts, Stop Toxic Incineration in Springfield, Partnership for Policy Integrity, Jones River Watershed Association, Masssachusetts Climate Action Network.


***


Act Now!  Tell Governor Deval Patrick and Lt. Governor Tim Murray to strengthen the biomass regulations.

1. Restore the 15% limit on harvested forest wood that can be used as eligible biomass fuel,
2. Fix the carbon accounting flaw
3. Require biomass units to achieve 60% efficiency, and
4. Keep the 2015 deadline for compliance by existing biomass units.

Send an email message by clicking here. Or call or write:

Governor Deval Patrick, State House, Room 280, Boston, MA 02133

Lt. Governor Tim Murray, State House, Room 280, Boston, MA 02133

Call: 617-725-4005  or  888.870.7770 (in state)


Background

Massachusetts has taken a strong step forward in recognizing that biomass combustion for electricity can undermine greenhouse gas reduction targets and harm forests. The state commissioned the Manomet Study and in July, 2010 announced its intent to align the Renewable Portfolio Standard with the Global Warming Solutions Act.

Instead of issuing regulations that are consistent with the July, 2010 letter, the Department of Energy Resources, under Secretary Rick Sullivan, wrote regulations that are too weak. These May, 2011 regulations have sparked serious concern from leading public interest advocates (see letters below):

Conservation Law Foundation

Mass Audubon

Environmental League of Massachusetts

Clean Water Action Alliance of Massachusetts

American Lung Association in Massachusetts

Environment Massachusetts

Massachusetts Climate Action Network

Massachusetts Breast Cancer Coalition

Toxics Action Center Campaign

Natural Resources Council of Maine

Natural Resources Defense Council

Sierra Club Massachusetts Chapter

Multi-Group Letter


Other group letters:

The Wilderness Society

Partnership for Policy Integrity

Clean Air Task Force

The Fletcher School, Tufts University


The process for approving the biomass regulations required the state Legislature’s joint committee on Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy to review them and issue a report. The report was issued on June 10, 2011.

Thanks for your help.  If you have any questions, give us a call at 800-729-1363.

Our Mission

The Stop Spewing Carbon Campaign is a grassroots effort to stop taxpayer subsidies for polluting, forest-burning biomass power incinerators in Massachusetts.

Stop Spewing Carbon Campaign continues to pressure the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to stop wasting your "clean energy" taxpayer & ratepayer dollars on inefficient, carbon dioxide-spewing, biomass power incinerators.

The Problem

Right now in Massachusetts, developers are proposing five new biomass incinerators that would produce only 1% more electricity, but would...

The Solution

End all renewable energy credits, tax credits, and cash grants to forest or garbage fueled power plants that burn dirty.  Work now to end public funding for polluting incinerators disguised as "clean" energy.

Demand that your tax dollars go to efficiency & conservation measures, as well as appropriately-sited & scaled, zero-waste & zero-emission renewable energy sources like solar, wind, small-hydroelectric (no new dams), small geothermal, and wave/tidal. 

You can take action here.